Skip to main content


About Lonelyville

Lonelyville is the place to go if you’re looking to get away from it all. The town is free from the commercial traffic and development that typify the western part of Fire Island. In fact, except for a few new larger houses and an annual "Walk for Peace" on September 11th, the town has changed very little during the past twenty years.

Lonelyville offers:

  • A laid-back, neighborly environment
  • The peace and quiet of an unspoiled natural setting
  • A wide, uncrowded beach

Some important facts about Lonelyville:

  • There are no shops or restaurants
  • Lonelyville has no direct ferry service. Residents access the town from the Dunewood ferry

Featured Properties for Rent

Rented for 2018 Fire Island
3 1.5 Bay-Side

LONELYVILLE Simply Living Well #12

This clean and neat three bedroom beach house has everything you need to enjoy your stay on Fire Island. 
learn more
Rented for 2018 Fire Island summer rental in Lonelyville #17
4 1.5 Bay-Side

LONELYVILLE Beach Living #17

This cottage is simple, clean and comfortable.
learn more
Rented for 2018 Fire Island vacation home for rent in Lonelyville
4 1.5 Bay-Side

LONELYVILLE Spacious Decks! #24

If you want privacy and quiet, Lonelyville may be the right community choice for you.
learn more

Featured Properties for Sale

$799,000 Fire Island real estate
4 1.5 Bay-Side

LONELYVILLE Beautifully Detailed and Tranquil

If you want privacy and quiet,  this move in ready beach house offers the best in Fire Island living.
learn more
$850,000 Fire Island vacant land
0 0 Bay Front

LONELYVILLE Bay Front Development Opportunity

This unique piece of land fronting on the Great South Bay is now available for purchase. 
learn more