Skip to main content
Find your Fire Island RentalRentBuy a Fire Island PropertyBuy
search properties
Search by Property ID#
search properties

Search Results

Two Week Minimum Rental Fair Harbor
3 1 Ocean-Side

Fair Harbor Steps to the Beach #10

$3,500 per week
This Fair Harbor beach cottage is just steps from the ocean yet convenient to everything in Fair Harbor
learn more
7.15 - 9.2; Two Week Minimum Fire Island rental in Fair Harbor
4 1 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Side Cottage #105

$4k per week
This four bedroom Fair Harbor summer rental is located on a beach block
learn more
7.12-719,8.2-8.9,8.16-8.23 Fair Harbor # 17
4 2 Bay Front

FAIR HARBOR Bay Front Living #17

$6,500 per week
Enjoy stunning sunset views from this spacious, family friendly
learn more
7.19 - 8.2; 8.9 - 8.16 Fair Harbor Beach House # 10 for rent
3 1 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Side Cottage #47

$3,200 per week
If you love Fair Harbor, this cottage is the essence of a Fair Harbor Fire Island beach cottage.
learn more
8.1 - 9.30 Fair Harbor Beach House # 30
3 1 Bay-Side

Fair Harbor; Back to Basics #30

$3k per week
Fair Harbor Beach House with four bedrooms ready for summer!
learn more
8/12 - 8/19 Fair Harbor Beach House for Rent
4 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Steps to the Beach #116

$4,200 per week
This Fair Harbor Beach House, just steps to the beach, has four bedrooms and a bath and a half. 
learn more
July Two Week Rental; 8.1 - 8.15 Fire Island
3 1 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Steps to the Beach #90

$5k per week
Lovely, updated Fair Harbor beach house located on the ocean block and just one house off the ocean.
learn more
August 9 -23 Fair Harbor Fire Island # 122
3 1 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Cottage Details #122

$3,500 per week
Located on one of the loveliest walks in Fair Harbor, this cottage offers comfort and charm.
learn more
August 2 - 16 Fair Harbor Vacation Rental with Two bedrooms
2 2 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Charming Cottage #109

$4,250 per week
Located on one of the loveliest bay side Fair Harbor walks, this cottage has some highly desirable amenities. 
learn more
August 1 - 27; Two Week Minimum Summer home for rent in Fair Harbor Fire Island
3 1.5 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Quiet Walk #107

$4,500 per week
This Fair Harbor bay side home has a number of features which make this a top rental choice.
learn more
8.2 - 8.30; TWO WEEK MINIMUM Summer Home in Fair Harbor on an ocean block
3 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Garden Delight #113

$4,125 per week
This three bedroom summer rental in Fair Harbor is located on an ocean block.
learn more
July 12 - August 2 Fair Harbor
3 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Steps to the Beach #77

$3,750 per week
This Fair Harbor beach house has good space in side and out
learn more