Skip to main content
Find your Fire Island RentalRentBuy a Fire Island PropertyBuy
search properties
Search by Property ID#
search properties

Search Results

Check for Availability Fair Harbor
4 2.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Plenty of Amenities #131

$4,500 per week
Fair Harbor Beach Cottage with every amenity
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor Beach House for Rent
4 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Steps to the Beach #116

Call per week
This Fair Harbor Beach House, just steps to the beach, has four bedrooms and a bath and a half. 
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor Ocean Views Summer Rental # 48
3 2 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Views #48

Call per week
Enjoy ocean breezes and ocean views from every room in this charming Fair Harbor Fire Island beach house.
learn more
Check for Availability Fire Island summer vacation rental near the beach
3 2 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Block #132

Call per week
Beach Side Rental in Fair Harbor with three bedrooms and spacious decks
learn more
October 1 - 31 Fair Harbor vacation rentals
4 2.5 Bay Front

FAIR HARBOR The Bay Front #13

$4k per week
BAY FRONT cottage with private bay beach! 
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor # 30
3 1 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Simply Living Well #30

$3,500 per week
Fair Harbor Beach House with three bedrooms ready for summer!
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor Beach House # 10 for rent
3 1 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Side Cottage #47

Call per week
If you love Fair Harbor, this cottage is the essence of a Fair Harbor Fire Island beach cottage.
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor
3 1.5 Bay-Side

Cottage Living in Fair Harbor #42

Call per week
Three bedroom summer cottage in Fair Harbor with a lovely garden and deck
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor
3 1 Ocean-Side

Fair Harbor Steps to the Beach #10

Call per week
This Fair Harbor beach cottage is just steps from the ocean yet convenient to everything in Fair Harbor
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor Beach house on an ocean block for rent
3 1 Ocean-Side

Fair Harbor Summer Time #103

Call per week
Location! Location! Location!  Summer in this Fair Harbor vacation home with three bedrooms.  The rear deck is private and shady.
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor Beach House Ready for Summer
4 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR By the Sea #129

Call per week
Enjoy the Sights and Sounds of the Ocean and the Beach all day and night
learn more
Check for Availability Fair Harbor
3 1 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Summer Bright #80

Call per week
This three bedroom beach house is the quintessential summer rental. 
learn more